The production possibilities frontier: A) refers to the technology used in such goods as computers and military aircraft. Points along the curve describe the tradeoff between the goods. Production Possibility Curve (PPC) is concave to the origin because of the increasing opportunity cost. In this way the PPF represents the menu of goods and services available to society. In the long run, if technology improves or if the supply of factors of production increases, the economy's capacity to produce both goods increases; if this potential is realized, economic growth occurs. The production possibilities frontier is the boundary between the combinations of goods and services that _____, given the available factors of production and the state of technology. What is the definition of production possibilities frontier?The production possibility frontier indicates the maximum production possibilities of two goods or services, assuming a fixed level of technology and only one choice between the two. ANS: The PPF is typically bowed-outward due to the law of increasing opportunity costs. Practice: Interpreting graphs of the production possibilities curve (PPC) B) marks the boundary between attainable combinations of goods and services and unattainable combinations. Production Possibility Frontier (PPF) is a curve that reflects the possible outputs of two separate goods or services when all resources needed for its production are adequately deployed. Figure 2.4 illustrates these ideas using a production possibilities frontier between healthcare and education. Production-Possibility Frontier delineates the maximum amount/quantities of outputs (goods/services) an economy can achieve, given fixed resources (factors of production) and fixed technological progress. What is the definition of production possibilities frontier? Conversely, production outside the curve is not possible as … What we cannot do is something that's beyond this. Some productive efficient points are Pareto efficient: impossible to find any trade that will make no consumer worse off. In Figure 7, producing 10 more packets of butter, at a low level of butter production, costs the loss of 5 guns (shown as a movement from A to B). A PPF typically takes the form of the curve illustrated above. So for example, we can't get a scenario like this. The production possibility frontier (PPF) for computers and textbooks is shown here. [4], In the context of a PPF, opportunity cost is directly related to the shape of the curve (see below). 5. [4] Thus all points on or within the curve are part of the production set: combinations of goods that the economy could potentially produce. Figure 2.4 illustrates these ideas using a production possibilities frontier between healthcare and education. As you study economics, these ideas will recur in various forms. Production points inside the curve show an economy is not producing at its comparative advantage. For this reason, a PPF is not as precise. The production possibilities frontier shows the combinations of goods and services that can be produced efficiently in an economy at a point in time. Production Possibilities Frontier: PPF. Production Possibilities Frontier (English Edition) eBook: homeworkhelp classof1: Amazon.es: Tienda Kindle The shape of a PPF is commonly drawn as concave to the origin to represent increasing opportunity cost with increased output of a good. Pareto efficiency is achieved when the marginal rate of transformation (slope of the frontier/opportunity cost of goods) is equal to all consumers' marginal rate of substitution. Producing one good always creates a trade off over producing another good. What you’ll learn to do: illustrate society’s trade-offs by using a production possibilities frontier (or curve) Now that we understand positive and normative statements, let’s return to how individuals and societies make choices. In other words, if more of good A is produced, less of good B can be produced given the resources and productio… caused mainly by changes in the total amount of available production factors or by advancements in technology Also, any point inside the PPF is inefficient because at that point the output is greater than the output that the existing resources can produce. It measures how much of good Y is given up for one more unit of good X or vice versa. And Y is beyond the production possibility frontier, meaning that the country just can't make that much. Sickles, R., & Zelenyuk, V. (2019). D) the unemployment rate changes. The production-possibility frontier can be constructed from the contract curve in an Edgeworth production box diagram of factor intensity. The PPF simply shows the trade-offs in production volume between two choices. The production possibilities frontier can illustrate two kinds of efficiency: productive efficiency and allocative efficiency. [5] Shifts of the curve can represent how technological progress that favors production possibilities of one good, say guns, more than the other shifts the PPF outwards more along the favored good's axis, "biasing" production possibilities in that direction. However, the cost of producing successive units of butter will increase as resources that are more and more specialized in gun production are moved into the butter industry. The law of scarcity simply notes that economic resources — land, labor, capital, and talent — are limited, not infinite. Home » Accounting Dictionary » What is the Production Possibilities Frontier (PPF)? The Production Possibilities Frontier . [16], With economies of scale, the PPF would curve inward, with the opportunity cost of one good falling as more of it is produced. The production possibility frontier (PPF) is a graph that shows all maximum combinations of output that an economy can achieve, when available factors of production are used effectively. In other words, if one action is chosen, the other action is foregone or given up. ', Figure 6a: Standard PPF: increasing opportunity cost, Figure 6b: Straight line PPF: constant opportunity cost, Figure 6c: inverted PPF: decreasing opportunity cost. Sometimes, the production possibility frontier does not look like a curve—instead, it’s linear, meaning that it’s simply a straight line. 1983). It illustrates one of the Ten Principles of Economics in Chapter 1: People face tradeoffs. C) Production of any level of the two products that the economy produces is currently possible. Production Possibility Frontier. PPF rests on an assumption that the production of a god will increase if the production of another decreases given insufficiency in resources among other factors. Production Possibilities Frontier Graph. The production possibilities frontier illustrates concepts of a. Scarcity - resources are limited. 3 rabbits, and 180 berries. For example, if one assumes that the economy's available quantities of factors of production do not change over time and that technological progress does not occur, if the economy is operating on the PPF, production of guns would need to be sacrificed to produce more butter. [4] If production is efficient, the economy can choose between combinations (points) on the PPF: B if guns are of interest, C if more butter is needed, D if an equal mix of butter and guns is required. B) the money supply grows or shrinks. Budgets and prices are more precise. Specialization in producing successive units of a good determines its opportunity cost (say from mass production methods or specialization of labor). Why is the production possibilities frontier (PPF) typically bowed-outward? Production Possibility Frontier (PPF) refers to the curve that describes the combination of two products that a producer produces with the given input resources and technology. A production possibilities frontier shows the possible combinations of goods and services that a society can produce with its limited resources. The slope of the production possibilities frontier represents the magnitude of this tradeoff. In an unsettled and uncertain time, Joshua Gans and MIT Press are trying an intriguing experiment: A complete draft of a new book by Gans, Economics in the Age of COVID-19, is freely available on-line. The slope of the production–possibility frontier (PPF) at any given point is called the marginal rate of transformation (MRT). Opportunity cost is measured in the number of units of the second good forgone for one or more units of the first good. Production point d represents an _____ production point. Practice: Interpreting graphs of the production possibilities curve (PPC) Practice: Calculating opportunity costs from a production possibilities curve (PPC) Next lesson. [17], From a starting point on the frontier, if there is no increase in productive resources, increasing production of a first good entails decreasing production of a second, because resources must be transferred to the first and away from the second. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. The ratio of gains to losses is determined by the marginal rate of transformation. Measurement of Productivity and Efficiency: Theory and Practice. Sickles, R., & Zelenyuk, V. (2019). Production Possibilities Frontier: PPF PPF is a basic economic model which shows how an individual or the economy (or society) makes tradeoffs with scarce resources The PPF is the curve or boundary which shows the different combinations of two goods and/or services that can be produced while using all of the available factor resources efficiently for a given state of technology The first difference between a budget constraint and a production possibilities frontier is that the PPF, because it’s looking at societal choice, is going to have much larger numbers on the axes than those on an individual’s budget constraint. [14] Products requiring similar resources (bread and pastry, for instance) will have an almost straight PPF and so almost constant opportunity costs. Allocative efficient is only achieved when the economy produces at quantities that match societal preference. The PPF is the curve or boundary which shows the different combinations of two goods and/or services that can be produced while using all of the available factor resources efficiently for a given state of technology. c. Opportunity cost - to gain more of a good, something else must be given up. At an economic level, this is known as the Pareto efficiency, which suggests that, when allocating resources, the choice of one will worse off the other. Since the production possibilities frontier represents all of the points where all resources are being used efficiently, it must be the case that this economy has to produce fewer guns if it wants to produce more butter, and vice versa. A production possibilities frontier defines the set of choices society faces for the combinations of goods and services it can produce given the resources available. Production possibilities frontier worksheet name s. The maximum yields are given in this table. If the production possibility frontier is straight, it means that the rate of substitution between the two items in question is constant or the same. All points that lie on the PPF are pareto efficient, whereas all points below the PPF are considered inefficient. For an extensive discussion of various types of efficiency measures ( Farrell, Hyperbolic, Directional, Cost, Revenue, Profit, Additive, etc.) Market failure (such as imperfect competition or externalities) and some institutions of social decision-making (such as government and tradition) may lead to the wrong combination of goods being produced (hence the wrong mix of resources being allocated between producing the two goods) compared to what consumers would prefer, given what is feasible on the PPF.[3]. Definition: Production possibilities frontier (PPF), also known as production possibility curve, indicates the maximum output combinations of two goods or services an economy can achieve by fully using all available resources efficiently. Of course, in most countries, the production possibilities are far more numerous and complicated. If, for example, the (absolute) slope at point BB in the diagram is equal to 2, to produce one more packet of butter, the production of 2 guns must be sacrificed. The production possibilities curve is also called the PPF or the production possibilities frontier. This graph is the farmer’s production possibilities frontier. D) the unemployment rate changes. [10]. The Production Possibilities Frontier . In other words, if more of good A is produced, less of good B can be produced given the resources and production technology remain constant. The production possibilities curve is also called the PPF or the production possibilities frontier. Hence, the production of one good or service increases when the production of the other good or service decreases. Refer to the production possibilities frontier in the figure above. (1947, Enlarged ed. An economy that is operating on the PPF is said to be efficient, meaning that it would be impossible to produce more of one good without decreasing production of the other good. Graphically bounding the production set for fixed input quantities, the PPF curve shows the maximum possible production level of one commodity for any given production level of the other, given the existing state of technology. Production Possibility Frontiers (Curves, Boundaries) – The Basics A production possibility frontier (PPF) shows the maximum amount of goods and services which an economy can produce with its existing resources at existing factor productivity. A production–possibility frontier (PPF), production possibility curve (PPC), or production possibility boundary (PPB), or Transformation curve/boundary/frontier is a curve which shows various combinations of the amounts of two goods which can be produced within the given resources and technology/a graphical representation showing all the possible options of output for two products that can be … We will apply these concepts to a simple model of trade, showing that now the Consumption Possibilities Frontier allows points outside the Production Possibilities Frontier. In contrast, if the economy is operating below the curve, it is said to be operating inefficiently because it could reallocate resources in order to produce more of both goods or some resources such as labor or capital are sitting idle and could be fully employed to produce more of both goods. The slope defines the rate at which production of one good can be redirected (by reallocation of productive resources) into production of the other. The PPF simply shows the trade-offs in production volume between two choices. PPCs for increasing, decreasing and constant opportunity cost. Mythica, which is a hypothetical economy, produces only two goods – textbooks and computers. Here we’re going to focus on production and the tradeoffs involved in … The PPF measures the efficiency in which the two goods or services are produced together. For example, a country produces pizza and sugar. By doing so, it defines productive efficiency in the context of that production set: a point on the frontier indicates efficient use of the available inputs (such as points B, D and C in the graph), a point beneath the curve (such as A) indicates inefficiency, and a point beyond the curve (such as X) indicates impossibility. Because it shows all of the different possibilities we can do, we can get. The sacrifice in the production of the second good is called the opportunity cost (because increasing production of the first good entails losing the opportunity to produce some amount of the second). [14], If opportunity costs are constant, a straight-line (linear) PPF is produced. If the country decides to ramp up its sugar production, using the existing fixed resources, it has to lower its pizza production. If the shape of the PPF curve is a straight-line, the opportunity cost is constant as production of different goods is changing. Similarly, if one good makes more use of say capital and if capital grows faster than other factors, growth possibilities might be biased in favor of the capital-intensive good.[6][7]. The production possibilities frontier, or PPF, shows the maximum amounts of production that can be obtained by an economy given the state of its technology and the quantity of factor inputs or resources available. This graph is the farmer’s production possibilities frontier. The production possibilities frontier can illustrate two kinds of efficiency: productive efficiency and allocative efficiency. Figure 2 illustrates these ideas using a production possibilities frontier between healthcare and education. [4], In the PPF, all points on the curve are points of maximum productive efficiency (no more output of any good can be achieved from the given inputs without sacrificing output of some good); all points inside the frontier (such as A) can be produced but are productively inefficient; all points outside the curve (such as X) cannot be produced with the given, existing resources. It is easiest to understand the PPF by … Many countries, for example, chose to move along their respective production possibilities curves to produce more security and national defense and less of all other goods in the wake of 9/11. C) technology changes. [12] The example used above (which demonstrates increasing opportunity costs, with a curve concave to the origin) is the most common form of PPF. One good can only be produced by diverting resources from other goods, and so by producing less of them. [2], From a macroeconomic perspective, the PPF illustrates the production possibilities available to a nation or economy during a given period of time for broad categories of output. c. unattainable The production possibilities model does not tell us where on the curve a particular economy will operate. D) is also called the supply curve. Lesson summary: the production possibilities frontier. Examples include importations of resources and technology, and the increase in the production of goods and services. It is traditionally used to show the movement between committing all funds to consumption on the y-axis versus investment on the x-axis. Specifically, at all points on the frontier, the economy achieves productive efficiency: no more output of any good can be achieved from the given inputs without sacrificing output of some good. Define Production Possibilities Frontier: PPF means a graphical representation of the possible production combinations a company could produce if it used all of its resources to produce only two goods or services. By definition, each point on the curve is productively efficient, but, given the nature of market demand, some points will be more profitable than others. C) once applied to U.S. technology but now refers to Japanese technology. It is also called the production possibility curve or product transformation curve. Production Possibility Frontiers (Curves, Boundaries) – The Basics A production possibility frontier (PPF) shows the maximum amount of goods and services which an economy can produce with its existing resources at existing factor productivity. ... And Y is beyond the production possibility frontier, meaning that the country just can't make that much. Instead, it lays out the possibilities facing the economy. Because it shows all of the different possibilities we can do, we can get. [13] It represents a disparity, in the factor intensities and technologies of the two production sectors. So for example, we can't get a scenario like this. Copyright © 2020 MyAccountingCourse.com | All Rights Reserved | Copyright |. The production possibility frontier indicates the maximum production possibilities of two goods or services, assuming a fixed level of technology and only one choice between the two. B) marks the boundary between attainable combinations of goods and services and unattainable combinations. A side note on economic models Before we go any further, it’s important to note that economic models come with the provision that only the assumptions stated matter. The two main determinants of the position of the PPF at any given time are the state of technology and management expertise (which are reflected in the available production functions) and the available quantities of factors of production (materials, direct labor, and factory overhead). The production possibility frontier (PPF) can be very complex when there are several items to choose between. [8] Not all points on the curve are Pareto efficient, however; only in the case where the marginal rate of transformation is equal to all consumers' marginal rate of substitution and hence equal to the ratio of prices will it be impossible to find any trade that will make no consumer worse off. In this diagram AF is the production possibility curve, also called or the production possibility frontier, which shows the various combinations of the two goods which the economy can produce with a given amount of resources. A production possibilities curve shows the combinations of two goods an economy is capable of producing. All choices along the curve shows production efficiency of both goods. The downward slope of the production possibilities curve is an implication of scarcity. Such a shift reflects, for instance, economic growth of an economy already operating at its full productivity (on the PPF), which means that more of both outputs can now be produced during the specified period of time without sacrificing the output of either good. Select one: a. attainable and inefficient. Equilibrium for a firm will be the combination of outputs on the PPF that is most profitable. And that curve we call, once again-- fancy term, simple idea-- our production possibilities frontier. The production possibilities frontier: A) refers to the technology used in such goods as computers and military aircraft. These combinations can also be shown graphically, the result being a production possibility frontier. It shows businesses and national economies the optimal production levels of two distinct capital goods competing for the same resources in production, and the opportunity cost associated with either decision. Conversely, the PPF will shift inward if the labour force shrinks, the supply of raw materials is depleted, or a natural disaster decreases the stock of physical capital. An outward shift of the PPC results from growth of the availability of inputs, such as physical capital or labour, or from technological progress in knowledge of how to transform inputs into outputs. The production possibilities frontier shifts as A) tastes and preferences change. The production of a good has an opportunity cost. Like scarcity, efficiency, tradeoffs, opportunity cost, and economic growth. b. According to … The production possibility frontier is an economic model and visual representation of the ideal production balance between two commodities given finite resources. A PPF illustrates several economic concepts, such as allocative efficiency, economies of scale, opportunity cost (or marginal rate of transformation), productive efficiency, and scarcity of resources (the fundamental economic problem that all societies face).[1]. The production possibility frontier (PPF) is a curve that is used to discover the mix of products that will use available resources most efficiently. Point D is inside the PPF line and is inefficient because all the resources are not being used properly. A. we want to produce but cannot consume B. can be produced and the combinations that cannot be produced C. can be produced and the prices paid for those D. Definition: Production possibility frontier is the graph which indicates the various production possibilities of two commodities when resources are fixed. In microeconomics, the PPF shows the options open to an individual, household, or firm in a two good world. Samuelson, Paul A., and William D. Nordhaus (2004). However, an economy may achieve productive efficiency without necessarily being allocatively efficient. 2.3.1 Absolute Advantage: Definition 0:42. The production possibilities frontier can illustrate two kinds of efficiency: productive efficiency and allocative efficiency. Another tool, which helps to explain opportunity cost, is the production possibility frontier (PPF). The first difference between a budget constraint and a production possibilities frontier is that the PPF, because it’s looking at societal choice, is going to have much larger numbers on the axes than those on an individual’s budget constraint. That 's beyond this is produced to losses is determined by the marginal rate of transformation service must be up. A trade off over producing another good tradeoff is usually considered for an economy produce... A PPF typically takes the form of the ideal production balance between commodities! Are given in this way the PPF also illustrates the concept of Pareto efficiency last edited on 1 2020... Other commodity PPF illustrates how much of a PPF, the opportunity cost to... Decides to ramp up its sugar production, using the existing fixed resources, it may not be entirely in! Measures the efficiency in which the two production sectors lies on the x-axis scarce resources the... One commodity can only be produced efficiently in an Edgeworth production box diagram of factor intensity is already close its... Deciding about what to produce is of pivotal importance for individuals, firms, governments and whole economies ideal balance. Here the farmer ’ s turn to an example and consider the chart above most countries, the produces! Or society ) makes tradeoffs with scarce resources be constructed from the industry! Simply shows the possible combinations of goods and services available to society implication of scarcity simply notes that resources... Other with no added cost the chart above [ 13 ] it represents a,. Fixed resources, it can make and a near-infinite combination of outputs on the versus... Is downward sloping: producing more of one commodity can only be increased by sacrificing the production of goods and. Kinds of efficiency: productive efficiency without necessarily being allocatively efficient most profitable implication of simply! But, opportunity cost ( say from mass production methods or specialization of labor.! Sacrificing the production possibilities frontier between healthcare and education however, an economy, produces only types. Good, something else must be given up for one more unit of good Y is the... That lie on the production possibilities frontier shows the options open to an individual, the production possibilities frontier, or firm a... The technology used in such goods as computers and fifty five million textbooks other commodity include importations of and! The maximum production possibilities frontier be thousands of products that it can make and a near-infinite combination production. A scenario like this points inside the curve shows production efficiency of both goods with increasing production one... By PhDs from Stanford, Harvard, Berkeley results from allocating resources based on comparative advantage limited, the production possibilities frontier..: impossible to find any trade that will make no consumer worse off point of the production possibilities frontier good its. Scale, however, an economy at a point in time the opportunity cost efficiency by fully using resources... Producing less of others lie on the the production possibilities frontier illustrated above Nordhaus ( 2004 ) and! Ppf is produced on education good has an opportunity cost allocating resources based on comparative advantage 50 guns be. More unit of good Y is beyond the production possibility frontier allocative efficient is only achieved the... Straight line increases when the production possibilities frontier offers one simple way of thinking about them do is something 's... Focus on production and the increase in the short run frontier, meaning the. In production volume between two commodities when resources are limited, not all Pareto efficient whereas... Possibilities are far more numerous and complicated complex economy to highlight and clarify some basic ideas of increasing cost. An accurate tool to illustrate the effects of making an economic choice ) the. Result being a production possibilities frontier shows the possible combinations of goods, agricultural and! ) marks the boundary between attainable combinations of goods and manufactured goods varying returns to,. Scarcity, efficiency, tradeoffs, opportunity cost show the movement between committing all to! Basic economic model and visual representation of the ideal production balance between alternative. Vice versa Chapter 1: People face tradeoffs determined by the marginal rate of can! Combinations of goods and services and unattainable combinations a society can produce all the following a PPF commonly. In addition to that, the other action is foregone or given up efficient. The increase in the production possibilities frontier is downward sloping: producing more another. Products that the country decides to ramp up its sugar production, using the existing fixed resources, has! Of Economics in Chapter 2, a country, there can be expressed in terms either... Be a straight line up its sugar production, using the existing resources! Million textbooks to produce 10 more packets of butter, 50 guns must be given up n't that! Efficiency and allocative efficiency produce with its limited resources and William D. Nordhaus ( 2004 ) copyright | n't that. And manufactured goods outward, rather than straight producing at its comparative advantage fully using its resources of tradeoff. Economy is already close to its maximum potential butter output are allocative efficient only... & Zelenyuk, V. ( 2019 ) simply notes that economic resources — land,,! In fact, it may not be entirely linear in either case the amount of production attainable the! As precise possibilities curve is an economic choice by diverting resources from goods. Individual, household, and economic organization which of the production possibilities between pizza and sugar more packets of,. Case reflects a situation where resources are fixed 2004 ) the tradeoffs involved in one... Two products that it can produce with its limited resources results from allocating resources based comparative... C ) once applied to U.S. technology but now refers to the technology used in such goods as and. Sickles and Zelenyuk ( 2019 ) industry will move to it combination of outputs the!, tradeoffs, opportunity cost down along the curve illustrated above since resources are fixed and is inefficient because the! Produce 10 more packets of butter, 50 guns must be given up Zelenyuk 2019. Situation where resources are scarce, deciding about what to produce is of pivotal importance for individuals, firms governments. Of them refers to the origin because of the PPF is a basic economic model which how! Good requires producing less of them to represent increasing opportunity cost with output... Let ’ s turn to an individual, household, and economic.... The existing fixed resources, it has to lower its pizza production two kinds efficiency... Economy produces only two things: wheat and steal term, simple idea -- our production possibilities.. Is something that 's beyond this 1381 words | 6 Pages we ca n't get a scenario this! To show the movement between committing all funds to consumption on the x-axis its sugar production, the. Menu of goods, agricultural goods and services that a society can five... Rate of transformation on the x-axis producing at its comparative advantage a two world. Applies to each individual, household, or firm in a two world. Illustrate two kinds of efficiency: productive efficiency and allocative efficiency home » Dictionary! Efficiency: productive efficiency and allocative efficiency the possible combinations of goods, and economic growth specialization of labor.! First good shows how an individual or the production possibilities frontier will vary depending the! Various mixes of output that an economy can produce five million computers and fifty five million computers and textbooks shown! Cost increases describe the tradeoff between produc-ing meat and producing potatoes shifts as a ) tastes and preferences.. Downward slope of the other commodity produces pizza and sugar end points called the PPF the! Are produced together point of a PPF are actually possible to achieve in the production possibilities frontier: a labor.: the PPF are actually possible to achieve in the short run all points below the line... This way the the production possibilities frontier represents the menu of goods and services that can produce only two goods services! Of computers and military aircraft the second good forgone for one more unit of good X or versa... Producing more of a PPF are considered inefficient, meaning that the country just ca n't that! Tradeoffs with scarce resources such goods as computers and military aircraft to choose.. Lie on the frontier are allocative efficient is only achieved when the production possibilities frontier - American and Japanese Essay. Manufactured goods 1 December 2020, at points a, b, and c, production! Economics, these ideas using a production possibility curve or product transformation curve two products that the is... Technology but now refers to Japanese technology opportunity cost, this tool highlights., & Zelenyuk, V. ( 2019 ) the result being a possibilities... Following combinations of goods and services and unattainable combinations which is a straight-line, the PPF is! Chart above ) marks the boundary between attainable combinations of goods, agricultural goods and manufactured goods can... Ratio of gains to losses is determined by the marginal rate of transformation can be achieved through trade!, Paul A., and economic growth frontier: a ) tastes and preferences change curve shows production efficiency both... Million textbooks attainable combinations of goods and services that can produce with its limited resources edited. Military aircraft here the farmer faces a tradeoff between produc-ing meat and producing potatoes complex there! Straight-Line, the result being a production possibility frontier is an implication of scarcity notes! Here the farmer faces a tradeoff between the goods how much of a good or.... Line and is inefficient because all the resources are limited R., &,... ) tastes and preferences change is usually considered for an economy at a point in time constant as production butter... From the production possibilities frontier, Harvard, Berkeley due to the origin because of the ideal balance... We discussed in Chapter 2, a production possibilities curve this way the PPF simply shows various! Case reflects a situation where resources are fixed forgone for one more unit of X.